Quote from: cgar on September 04, 2021, 02:18 AM
It's pretty hilarious complaining about the module. Team order has always been available in the replay file for any would be cheater to exploit. This module just exposes that "cheating" in the open.
So in effect being against wkWormOrder is doing more to defend cheating than fight against it.
Nobody in this thread said it was cheating. Though, it is obvious why it could be considered cheating.
Just because some things are possible does not mean people should not complain about those and other related things.
While I am aware you can extract information from a replay file, is it possible to do it during an actual game, or only after? If this is possible during a game, this is something I did not know about, and there should be measures taken to prevent this as well. Of course, it should not be allowed either.
This is not publicly available knowledge as far as I am aware, or is it? In a way we should thank you for bringing this to our attention for those of us who were not already aware.
You clearly have superior knowledge and experience about replay files, so it is a good thing you are not playing league games and abusing that. However that does not stop this module from degrading an aspect of skill and experience in strategic schemes, quite an important one actually in Intermediate.
If I knew people were using this in CWT - I would refuse to stream it.
This actually gives me an idea to prevent cheating/abuse.
Quite frankly, the short conversation in this thread before has me a little concerned about how easy it is for skilled computer programmers to create and use their own modules to get an advantage in this game. Modules they make for private use only.
I believe there are ways to inspect replay files and detect if any extra module was loaded/used, am I wrong? Though the concern is, like avoiding real life police undetected, most replays are not checked on TUS if nobody raises an issue, or voices some concern about suspicious gameplay.
Would it be possible to develop some sort of code based algorithm which could scan games automatically as they are reported and compare them with a database of 'legal modules'. If anything new or illegal pops up, it would automatically send a message to a moderator or MonkeyIsland and it could be inspected further or deleted.